Fast Filters

Live & Upcoming

MLS iconMLS
Seattle Sounders FC logoSporting Kansas City logo
In 0m
SEA vs KAN

Browse

NHL logoNHL
Carolina Hurricanes logoFlorida Panthers logo
In 0m
HUR vs PAN

Browse

NHL logoNHL
Toronto Maple Leafs logoMontreal Canadiens logo
In 0m
LEA vs CAN

Browse

NHL logoNHL
Vegas Golden Knights logoChicago Blackhawks logo
In 0m
KNI vs BLA

Browse

NHL logoNHL
Edmonton Oilers logoVancouver Canucks logo
In 0m
OIL vs CAN

Browse

Everton VS Sunderland Prediction & Betting Tips - AI Analysis & Odds (May 17, 2026)

Everton FC logo

Everton

1 - 3

HT: 1-0

Sunderland AFC logo

Sunderland

Premier League·Everton Stadium

Comparison of analyst and AI predictions

Predicto AI

Predicto AI

Sunderland AFC to win

@4.00
View Reasoning
Sunderland AFC has a competitive edge with a recent win rate of 39% compared to Everton's 33% and a better overall goal-scoring rate in this matchup. While both teams have a similar CS rate of 25%, Sunderland’s slightly better form and ability to secure wins in away matches makes them a viable option for victory. Thus, betting on Sunderland AFC to win offers a promising opportunity.
Human Analyst

Human Analyst

Correct

Both Teams to Score

@1.65
View Reasoning
Both teams have shown a strong tendency to score, with Everton FC having a BTTS rate of 65% and Sunderland AFC at 45%. Historical head-to-head matchups also suggest a high-scoring nature, with 42 goals across 15 encounters, indicating that both sides can find the net. Given these stats, betting on both teams to score appears to be a solid choice.
Split call — see both takes above

Recent Form Analysis

Everton’s season has been a mixed bag with six wins, seven draws, and seven losses, reflecting inconsistency in their performances. Sunderland, meanwhile, have edged ahead slightly with seven victories but also show defensive vulnerabilities, having conceded 30 goals just like Everton. Both teams share a 25% clean sheet record, indicating defensive frailties that could be exploited in this encounter. Everton’s home advantage at Everton Stadium adds pressure on Sunderland, who will look to capitalize on their better winning ratio this season.

Goals & Defensive Patterns

The offensive output from both sides is moderate, with Everton scoring 29 goals and Sunderland netting 22 so far in the league. However, both teams concede goals at a similar rate, each with 30 goals against, pointing to an open game scenario. Everton’s matches see over 2.5 goals 55% of the time, while Sunderland’s games cross this threshold half the time. Notably, Everton’s BTTS rate of 65% suggests they are more prone to matches where both sides score, compared to Sunderland’s 45%, making a Both Teams to Score bet a compelling option.

Historical Head-to-Head

In their last 15 meetings, Everton have come out on top eight times, with Sunderland securing five wins and two draws completing the picture. These encounters have been relatively high scoring, averaging 2.8 goals per game with 42 goals across those matches. The historical tendency for goals and competitive balance hints that neither side will settle for a defensive stalemate, reinforcing the likelihood of goals at both ends.

Tactical Considerations

Everton’s approach at home typically leans towards a balanced attack with an emphasis on controlling possession, but their defensive lapses have resulted in a modest clean sheet record of just 25%. Sunderland, on the other hand, have shown resilience on the road but are susceptible to conceding, which could be exploited by Everton’s forwards. Sunderland’s ability to score 22 goals away from home suggests they won’t shy away from attacking, making this a contest where both teams look to assert themselves offensively.

Prediction Summary

The data points to a match where both teams are likely to find the net, supported by Everton’s 65% BTTS rate and Sunderland’s 45%, coupled with their identical goals conceded tally of 30. The expert prediction favors Both Teams to Score at odds around 1.75, a solid bet given the attacking tendencies and defensive vulnerabilities. Meanwhile, the AI’s pick of a Sunderland win offers value at approximately 4.51, reflecting Sunderland’s slightly better form and potential to upset at Everton Stadium. Overall, backing BTTS offers a safer, statistically grounded option, while a Sunderland win presents an intriguing underdog wager.

Martin Anderson
Martin Anderson
Human analyst

Professional betting analyst with 10+ years of experience in sports data analytics and statistics. Featured on The Athletic, 433, and ESPN. Currently maintaining a 70% win rate this season across European football markets. See the public track record.

Read Full Match Preview

Frequently Asked Questions

What's your prediction for this match?

The prediction for Everton FC vs Sunderland AFC leans towards both teams scoring given their offensive and defensive records. Everton's 6 wins, 7 draws, and 7 losses with 29 goals scored and 30 conceded indicate a balanced but vulnerable side. Sunderland, with 7 wins, 4 draws, and 9 losses, has scored fewer goals (22) but conceded the same number (30). The strong head-to-head history favoring Everton (8 wins to Sunderland's 5) suggests a competitive match likely ending in a 2-1 or 2-2 scoreline, with goals expected from both sides.

Which team has better recent form?

Everton FC's season shows a fairly balanced performance with 6 wins, 7 draws, and 7 losses, scoring 29 and conceding 30 goals. Sunderland AFC has a slightly better win count at 7 but fewer draws (4) and more losses (9), scoring fewer goals (22) but conceding the same number (30). Both teams have a clean sheet percentage of 25%, reflecting defensive vulnerabilities. Everton's slightly higher BTTS rate of 65% compared to Sunderland's 45% indicates Everton's games are more likely to feature goals from both sides.

What are the best betting opportunities?

The best betting markets for Everton FC vs Sunderland AFC include Both Teams to Score (BTTS) and Over 2.5 Goals. Everton has a BTTS rate of 65% and Sunderland 45%, making BTTS a strong option given Everton's attacking tendencies. Over 2.5 goals is also attractive with Everton's 55% and Sunderland's 50% occurrences, supported by their combined 60 goals conceded this season. Clean sheets are less likely, with both teams only managing 25% clean sheet rates, so markets favoring goals and BTTS are advisable.

How do these teams match up historically?

The head-to-head record between Everton FC and Sunderland AFC over 15 matches shows Everton with 8 wins, Sunderland with 5, and 2 draws. A total of 42 goals have been scored across these encounters, averaging 2.8 goals per game. This history suggests a relatively high-scoring and competitive fixture, with Everton having a slight edge in victories.

What are the key tactical matchups?

Tactically, Everton FC tends to have a balanced approach with 29 goals scored and 30 conceded, indicating a mix of attacking intent and defensive vulnerability. Sunderland AFC, scoring 22 and conceding 30, shows a less potent attack but similar defensive frailties. Both teams share a 25% clean sheet rate, suggesting matches may open up. Everton’s higher BTTS rate (65%) versus Sunderland’s 45% points to Everton likely pushing forward more aggressively, while Sunderland may look to capitalize on counterattacks.

Should I bet on the favorite or underdog?

The AI prediction favors Sunderland AFC to win, despite Everton's stronger head-to-head record and home advantage. Sunderland's better win tally this season (7 vs 6) and potential to capitalize on Everton's defensive lapses offer value as underdogs. Given both teams concede frequently and Everton's propensity for draws (7), betting on Sunderland or a BTTS market may provide good value. Everton's home form is solid but inconsistent, so the underdog Sunderland could offer worthwhile odds.

Explore more predictions

Best betting partners on this match

Top pick
Megapari logo

Megapari

9.7(789)

200% Welcome Bonus up to $100

Why we picked this: Covers over 40+ sports including eSports

Reviewed by our team
visa
skrill
tether
bitcoin
ethereum
22Bet logo

22Bet

9.9

100% Welcome Bonus up to €122

Reviewed by our team
visa
skrill
tether
bitcoin
Claim Free BetTerms & Conditions · 18+
Betwinner logo

Betwinner

9.5

Exclusive 100% Sports Bonus up to $130

Reviewed by our team
visa
skrill
tether
bitcoin
Claim Free BetTerms & Conditions · 18+
Melbet logo

Melbet

9.3

100% Sportsbook Bonus up to €100

Reviewed by our team
visa
skrill
tether
bitcoin
Claim Free BetTerms & Conditions · 18+
1WIN logo

1WIN

8.9

500% Welcome Package up to €1000

Reviewed by our team
visa
skrill
tether
bitcoin
Claim Free BetTerms & Conditions · 18+
888 Starz logo

888 Starz

9.1

100% Sports Bonus up to €100

Reviewed by our team
visa
skrill
tether
bitcoin
Claim Free BetTerms & Conditions · 18+

This match has ended

See Today's Picks
We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. For more information on how we use cookies, please see our cookie policy.